This is what they did:
This is what they were trying to do (redirected):
In the first picture the puppeteers are "feeling it" - you can see them feeling it. They are full of earnest passion. All three of them. Pushing the puppet over the edge of the table to show us that he's looking over the edge. But the puppet isn't thinking or feeling anything. The puppet is passive, pushed over the edge of the table, off balance.
In the second one however the puppet is thinking. You can see the puppet thinking. You know what it is thinking and guess at what it is feeling, just from looking at it.
Or to put it another way, you are feeling what you're seeing.